Earlier this year, the group Invisible Children took over the Youtube community by storm with their Kony 2012. The video showcased footage of child abuse in Uganda led by a dictator, Kony. This video was shocking, showing violent footage, and using the narrator's young son to send an arrow straight through the viewer's heart. This video asked for donations in order to send more troops to Uganda before the end of the year and to stop the violence. This video gained support rapidly across the country, with a lot of people donating to the cause. However, it was later found that this donation money was not being used entirely to the cause.
So who determines how in the wrong Invisible Children are for their hyperbole? The idea and intent was clearly for good. Trying to stop a real issue going in the world today. However, it takes more than donations and internet support to stop a ruthless, murderous dictator. Also, Kony was believed to not even be in Uganda anymore and sending troops there may be pointless and lead to hostility against America. The exaggeration in facts also strayed from the truth. It was indeed for the purpose of getting people to recognize the issue and take a stand on it, but what makes it okay to blatantly lie to people, even for a good cause?
Conveniently, this video came out during the semester where we listened to a podcast on NPR telling of the horrid conditions in Apple factories in Japan. Later, the storyteller, Mike Daisy, came back on the show and admitted that he exaggerated the truth and a lot of the information he originally provided he did not personally see. Again, this hyperbole was meant for good, trying to stop a real issue going on in the world. After the original podcast, lots of listeners took strides to help the cause and share the clip with other people. However, when people find out that they are blatantly lied to, they kind of get a little sour. No one likes being lied to and betraying people's trust is one of the worst things a human can do.
I appreciate that both of these had good intent. These issues ARE real and need to be stopped somehow, someday, but it will take a long time, and a lot more effort. For the Kony folk, the fact that the donation money was not used properly and that is just another way of showing that they are not credible. I truly believe that Mike Daisy has real intent of good, and wanted to make a change about the factory issues that he did witness. The exaggeration in his story only made it more unique and astounding, easier to grasp the attention of listeners and get them to join his cause. However, the radio show is known for always telling the truth, and nothing else. The NPR guys brought him on the show trusting that he was telling of the true account that he witnessed. The fact the he betrayed their trust and hurt the reputation of their radio show is not okay and not fair.
However, overall I appreciate that both causes had good intent and wanted to stop terrible things that are going on in the world today. But what and who defines "truth" and the limits on the word?
Not only does this post show the effects that these events have on people directly, but they also help to show other effects. I work at Wegmans, and many times throughout the year we collect money for different charities including Check-out Hunger and the United Way. But many people won't donate any money because they don't believe that the money is actually going to the cause that it says it's going to. Situations like the Kony video or the Podcast about apple make it difficult for honest charities to get money, because these other things give charities a bad name. So not only does it affect the cause directly, but it also causes negative affects to other charities. And personally, the Kony thing was weird to begin with. I actually never watched the whole video because I had already heard so many things about it, good and bad. A lot of people just made jokes about it, so I wasn't sure what to believe and I wasn't sure if this was a "trustworthy" charity. and then especially since the guy got arrested a few months later, seems a little sketchy to me. I'm not so sure how much I trust that guy honestly. but you never know i guess
ReplyDelete