So i'm gonna assume everyone knows what auto-tune is and what it does to digital vocal tracks. In a nutshell, it makes the vocalist's voice sound exactly how the producer/band/singer/singer's mom wants it; perfect you could say. I wrote my last essay partially on this topic, relating it to Walter Benjamin's "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" and arguing that it is a negative technology and, as Benjamin describes, adds a distraction to the overall product as a whole. In reality, I don't mind the idea of auto-tune at all; just how it is being used today.
Why not make recordings absolutely as perfect as possible? Thousands of dollars, countless hours of work, and lots of stress go into recording; the artist should be 100% satisfied with the final product. In the studio, vocals normally take the longest to record. For vocalists, it often takes multiple attempts to get a take to sound how they want it. Auto-tune allows them to take a track that has slight inaccuracies and make a minor adjustment to the notes to make them the correct pitch. It saves a lot of time. For people who can actually sing, I think auto-tune is an amazing tool that can add interesting effects to the sound of voice and takes away some of the stress of having to get every single part absolutely perfect.
However, the problem is that people who can't sing now use auto-tune. And people have gotten famous for it nonetheless. This is what bothers me. There are plenty of talented people whose dream is to make it big and to play their music for people. These are the people who should be getting recognized. Also, I don't like when an artist used auto-tune in concert. If it's me, I paid to hear them live. If the artist can't put on a good live show without the assistance of digital effects, then they don't deserve the recognition that they get.
In regards to Benjamin, I argued that the use of digital effects takes away from the human aspect of the musician. Being a musician myself, I love finding out anything that shows that my favorite artists are still just normal people who deal with the same problems and stress I experience. With them being "perfect" in these recording and during live performances thanks to auto-tune, they seem like some superhuman people who never make mistakes. Everyone makes mistakes and sometimes, in my opinion, it's nice to hear a mistake during a live performance or something. You can relate to it. It allows you to connect to them and adds to the overall music and performance as a whole.
Obviously there are plentyyy more arguments to this, but I don't want to go on a tangent. What do you guys think?