Monday, April 16, 2012

Auto-Tune Fascination

So i'm gonna assume everyone knows what auto-tune is and what it does to digital vocal tracks. In a nutshell, it makes the vocalist's voice sound exactly how the producer/band/singer/singer's mom wants it; perfect you could say. I wrote my last essay partially on this topic, relating it to Walter Benjamin's "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" and arguing that it is a negative technology and, as Benjamin describes, adds a distraction to the overall product as a whole. In reality, I don't mind the idea of auto-tune at all; just how it is being used today.

Why not make recordings absolutely as perfect as possible? Thousands of dollars, countless hours of work, and lots of stress go into recording; the artist should be 100% satisfied with the final product. In the studio, vocals normally take the longest to record. For vocalists, it often takes multiple attempts to get a take to sound how they want it. Auto-tune allows them to take a track that has slight inaccuracies and make a minor adjustment to the notes to make them the correct pitch. It saves a lot of time. For people who can actually sing, I think auto-tune is an amazing tool that can add interesting effects to the sound of voice and takes away some of the stress of having to get every single part absolutely perfect.

However, the problem is that people who can't sing now use auto-tune. And people have gotten famous for it nonetheless. This is what bothers me. There are plenty of talented people whose dream is to make it big and to play their music for people. These are the people who should be getting recognized. Also, I don't like when an artist used auto-tune in concert. If it's me, I paid to hear them live. If the artist can't put on a good live show without the assistance of digital effects, then they don't deserve the recognition that they get.

In regards to Benjamin, I argued that the use of digital effects takes away from the human aspect of the musician. Being a musician myself, I love finding out anything that shows that my favorite artists are still just normal people who deal with the same problems and stress I experience. With them being "perfect" in these recording and during live performances thanks to auto-tune, they seem like some superhuman people who never make mistakes. Everyone makes mistakes and sometimes, in my opinion, it's nice to hear a mistake during a live performance or something. You can relate to it. It allows you to connect to them and adds to the overall music and performance as a whole.

Obviously there are plentyyy more arguments to this, but I don't want to go on a tangent. What do you guys think?

4 comments:

  1. You know, when I read this article the person I thought of is Rebecca Black. It is true that our music talent have been dropping. More and more people are becoming famous due to auto-tune, even though they cannot sing. Technology have change the nature of music for the better and the worst. However for us, we can only support those who can really sing. There are music out their that doesn't even use an actual person. It may sound weird to you, but there have been a creation that samples music from artist and places them in to computers. From the computer you can write up the lyrics, set up the note to be sang for that word in the song, basically you are creating the songs with the voice of other artists. The creation is called Vocaloids, which were created by the Japanese. These are software that are becoming popular artists, not actual people.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am a true music aficionado. I love music shows like the sing off x factor and of course American idol. I was watching an episode of American idol the other night and a contestant that form a previous season came back to perform. I was super excited because I really enjoyed this person’s voice. I sometimes sing one of the songs he covered, while I shower, so no one can hear me of course. Nevertheless, I was supper exited because this person can really sing so I am assuming he is going to sing a pretty ballade show off his pips but to my amazement, he did not. He sang some club song with auto-tune covering up his voice. I was appalled I could not believe what I was hearing. You could obviously tell that auto-tune was being used and this person does not need it, he has an amazing voice.
    Technology serves many purposes but I could make millions if I sang a few songs with auto-tune. This technology makes people who really can sing look badly because they do not use it. It is a tough call, whether this is a good thing or bad. I do not really like it because I know there singers out there who like Tommy said work hard to make sure that there records are spot on and other people can just jump in the booth and do not have to worry so much because they know that the auto-tune will cover it up. It all depends on how you look at it. However just because you sound good does not mean people are going to buy your stuff, others people however have made large profit of off using auto-tune. Technology always has it pros and cons it all depends on whose hands it is in and what they plan on doing with it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a very important topic, especially where we are with music today. Although many people cannot tell, all artists use auto-tune. It might be hard to tell, but even when someone sounds exactly like they do live (which isn’t a long list), they use some type of software in the recording studio to edit the song to perfection. Although it is a very powerful tool, many up and coming artists use it more and more. When I think Auto tune, I think T-Pain. Everyone who has listened to even one song of his, or one that he is featured in, can tell when T-Pain “sings”. It sounds like they turned the Auto tune power to the max, and every sound that comes out of his mouth fluxuates to sound like a robot. Although it sounds cool in some applications, T-Pain’s career is based off this electronic program. Many up and coming artists use it because without it, they would have no shot at a career. I agree that digital effects such as Auto tune take away from a musician’s raw talent, but it doesn’t look like anything is going to change anytime soon. Until then, artists will enjoy their millions of dollars while we hold our ears.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is an interesting topic, especially for me being a musician who has recorded in a studio before. On top of it, I'm a singer so I can relate to it even more. When going into a studio to track vocals, a lot of times the producer or whoever you're working with will have you take only one or two tracks of vocals, and then say that he'll just fix any minor problems. This bothers me a lot actually, and when they say that, I'll usually just tell them that I'll do it again until I get it the way I want it to sound. Not everything on a recording needs to sound perfect, I completely agree. Hearing something that isn't perfect is a lot of times better for me, because you can feel the "raw energy" of the performance. In many cases, music today is over-produced, to the point where it doesn't even sound real anymore, which to me makes it not even worth listening to. And I also agree with what you said about performers making mistakes live. If I see a show, and they make a mistake, it's funny because you can sit there and think "yea, I've been there." It's something that can make a show memorable.

    ReplyDelete