Sunday, February 12, 2012

Rant About Illegally Downloading

Lee Siegel's "Being Human in the Age of the Electronic Mob" begins with the metaphor comparing two "of the more marvelous inventions of humankind," the automobile and the Internet. I highly agree that these two inventions have completely changed the way we live in an overall positive way. I can't even fathom the difficulty of some our now "everyday tasks" without them, but i'm gonna focus on the less common sides of these arguments.

It seems that everyone nowadays, including our own campus, is turning "green." I'll admit that i'm extremely dedicated when it comes to things such as recycling, or turning unused lights or water off. But let's face it, the automobile is arguably the main reason why this "Green Movement" is even necessary. Imagine how many cars you see on the thruway when you drive it. Now multiply that by 734289403028134029 or some number around that i'm sure, and that's the number of cars giving off greenhouses gases and emissions every single day. Anyways, that's not the point of this blog. Just a look at the less considered side of that argument. Now for SOPA.

Overall, the bill was absolutely ridiculous and thank god that it didn't pass. But being as musician myself and having a friend with an album on iTunes which includes a song I wrote, I completely understand where this bill is coming from. I don't think people realize how much time and money is put into recorded just one song, let alone a whole album. My band in high school professionally recorded four songs for $1200, and that was a discounted price because it was a family friend. And that doesn't include mixing, mastering, packaging, etc. Musicians put their entire lives into writing and recording their music. As Richard Florida stated “That driving force is the rise of human creativity as the key factor in our economy and society” (Florida 198). Human society is beginning to be run by creative minds and talents in every industry. By illegally downloading music and saving yourself a mere $10 or so, you're tearing apart their creativity and not rewarding them for dedicating their lives to providing you with the music you're listening to. Everyone always says"oh, music gets me through life" or "I don't know what i'd do without music," then what's the big deal about spending a little money on the music that gets you through life. I follow one of my favorite musicians, Jason Lancaster of the band Go Radio, on twitter and he has been in the studio literally all day for the past two or three weeks recording their new album. Musicians aren't rich people, if their music keeps being illegally downloaded, they won't be able to continue to shell out the money it takes to make new music. Their goes the music that gets you through life. It's just a shame that people today think that it's okay to save themselves just a tiny bit of money by illegally downloading. We're selfish beings.


ANYWAYS, moral of the story. SOPA had the right idea, yet went about it the wrong way. Hopefully when a more thought out and efficient bill is proposed, people won't let their selfish wants hurt the creativity of the people providing you with the things you love in life. 
 

6 comments:

  1. I completely agree with your arguments, especially those regarding how individuals are depriving musical artists of their hard work and compensation; unfortunately, the issue of music piracy will likely remain for years to come. In my opinion, SOPA was a failure because they tried to accomplish far too much, too quickly. In my opinion, If SOPA were an infant, it tried to run before it learned to crawl. Alternatively, from a historical perspective, if you look at other major legislation, especially those found during the Civil Rights era, it is apparent that such change took decades of confrontation and lack of agreement. Perhaps this will be the same case in the realm of internet file sharing and communication. SOPA may serve as a step in the right direction, as its purpose was to ultimately support creative endeavors, but the methods behind the act will have to be amended before the general public will be accepting of such a drastic change.
    I believe the internet superpowers of Wikipedia and Google also defended themselves brilliantly against SOPA, which potentially threatened their respective livelihoods as information centers and massive search engines. Wikipedia blacked their own servers out for a day in protest of SOPA; obviously, this drew attention from citizens (and, more importantly, voters) who might otherwise not know about or understand SOPA. Ultimately, this will be a serious issue for years to come. As has been the case for decades, the courts and legislation have to catch up to the adapting standards of technology. Now, more than ever before.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you in that people should by their songs on ITunes. It’s horrible to think that artists trying to make it are not because of people buying their songs illegally. SOPA really did have a get idea, but as you said approached it the wrong way were it seemed to violate our rights. We watched this show in class about how YouTube Videos, children singing songs by other artists would be illegal in the eyes of Sopa. They gave the example of Justin Bieber, and his YouTube videos before being discovered. What triggered me watching this video was the aspect of American Idol. American Idol is considered the American Dream. Contestants on the show sing songs by various artists in front of judges who will depict if they will in fact go to “Hollywood.” The question I am bringing up is, isn’t that the same thing the video in class was targeting Justin Bieber for. The people on the show are not call up the artist they are singing and ask them if they could audition with this song. American Idol could have asked collectively though, we just are not told this information, so I mean they could have consent, but so could of Justin Bieber. I feel that the Sopa Bill trying to be past was quite ridiculous on the fact there would be a lot of hearsay involved when trying to persecute people. I am all for doing things the right, and not taking short cuts, but how far is the government going?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with this argument about the new SOPA act. I know that SOPA was mainly trying to protect what people have created to help stop piracy, but it did go about it in the wrong way. I would not be happy if sites such as Youtube had to delete over half of their videos just because someone is trying to recreate an already played song and try to make it their own. Honestly I would think that someone recreating music would please an artist, who wouldn't want their song to be sung by other people? It only means that you're catchy enough and apparently good enough for people to take interest. The government would be so wrong if they took away our rights to that extent, we have lived this way for so long and changing something so quickly would definitely ruin so many sites such as youtube and tumblr etc.. For the illegal downloading aspect of this, I agree that it should be stopped. But how is this possible? The internet is so large that if one site was shut down two more would open up and its not very hard to find a site with free music. But I have also been noticing that on Facebook, if you like an artists page many times you get their music for free now because of the fact that they know their music isn't going to be bought, but it is going to be leaked right when they release it. It is sad that artists these days are unable to get the amount of recognition that they deserve.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree completely about the covers on Youtube of certain band's songs, Emily. If someone has taken the time to learn the song, perfect it, and record it so they can share it with others, that's an honor to an artist...I would think. They're in no way trying to harm the band who created it and oftentimes they give credit in the description box or something. If the only legal way to get "approval" is to contact the actual artist or record label, then there's is no point in going through the hassle just to show that you appreciate a song enough to learn it yourself. Also, some people's dreams are to get noticed for playing music and this is sometimes the only way they can. Two bands that come to mind for me, Boyce Avenue and Karmin (check them both out - amazing) got noticed by posting covers on Youtube...some even better than the originals in my opinion. And they're no doubt better than 90% of famous musicians today. Sure they could have played local shows for years, hoping that one day some big name label rep or someone happened to notice them, but how realistic is that? Being online means you're viewable to the ENTIRE world...well...anyone with internet access that is. Point is, in a way, taking away the ability to post covers on Youtube is taking away someone trying to achieve their dreams. Everyone always says never give up on your dreams, so why ruin it for unknown, talented musicians?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I believe it is safe to say that the two most impacting inventions in modern history are the automobile and the internet. Both of these inventions have drastically improved the lives of countless individuals, thereby making their work lives and day to day personal lives easier and more efficient.
    At the time of the beginning of the twentieth century, the automobile was known as a luxury item. This is hard for many people to believe nowadays although this was the truth of the situation about one hundred years ago. People one hundred years ago would think to themselves, "Oh, how it would be nice to have a car to make getting around from place to place easy, convenient, and fast". Before, people had to either walk or ride horses to travel. This has all changed and now most people in America and much of the rest of the world have cars to make their lives better. The results have been more interaction between more people and more communication amongst them. This has been an effective way of interacting and would have been thought of as a “long-stretch” without such an invention as the automobile.
    Many people around the world also have computers with internet capability. The internet has been a great way for people from all over the world to communicate with one another and share and obtain information. As a result, people have become more educated and have been exposed to things that they would otherwise not have ever been exposed to if the internet didn’t exist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have to agree with you and say that SOPA was ridiculous, but what views do you have saying as to why? Ha I’ll tell you my reason…
      The thing that got me about that dumb proposal is that in many regards it was subjective because not only did it directly influence the piracy website, but other mainstream sites that could have any link to file sharing. This would mean that not only would the “free mp3” sites be banned and taken down, but so would Youtube, Facebook, Google, etc. Imagine the internet without Google for heaven’s sake! That would completely turn the web topsy turbby. We would be forced into using other search engines that nobody likes. But, oh, wait- those would be banned also. See where I’m getting at? The whole point of Youtube and Facebook is to share, whether a video, picture or whatever. Granted there would be sharing of videos that have songs and such. So would that be illegally sharing a song? This is where I thought the whole act got messy because they (being the government) could stretch the boundaries of what they would determine to be illegal. With that said, the complete idea of SOPA is argumentative.

      Delete